CHAPTER THREE: DEMOCRACY AND POLITICAL GOVERNANCE
__________________________________________________________________________
206.
With regard to the independence of the legislature, the National Assembly
is certainly independent. The constitution even accords it one section (Section
5) just as it does the Executive. Its functions – the exercise of legislative
authority and control of government activities – are set out in the constitution.
The National Assembly passes its own bylaws but is controlled by the
Constitutional Court, as is stipulated in the constitution. However, a large
number of Beninese nationals believe that the National Assembly is not
playing its role of watchdog over government activities effectively. This gives
rise to a need to enhance the functions of the National Assembly to include
monitoring the implementation of the national budget.
207.
With regard to the independence of the judiciary, most Beninese citizens
see the judiciary as an extension of the Executive, since the Executive wields
some influence over it – despite the existence of a law that establishes its
independence. The CSAR focuses on a number of problems plaguing the
judicial system. These include corruption, disputes about jurisdiction, and the
weakness of the judiciary. To strengthen the judiciary and make it
independent, it has become necessary to make the president of the Supreme
Court the chairperson of the JSC, to dismiss unscrupulous judges and
encourage the honest ones, and to highlight the best practices of the judiciary
in order to enhance the confidence of the citizens in their justice system.
ii.
Conclusions of the CRM
Constitutional provisions establishing the separation of powers
208.
Available documents provide a wealth of information about the existing
constitutional and legislative provisions on the separation and balance of
powers in the country. Each of the powers is dealt with in a separate section of
the constitution. The supplementary provisions on each power are set out in
the establishment acts, which were adopted by a different majority than the
majority that passes ordinary laws. The Constitutional Court must ensure that
the establishment acts conform to the constitution.
209.
Several of the provisions of the 1990 constitution deal with the independence
of each power and the differences between the executive, legislative and
judiciary functions in a presidential system of government where separation of
powers is strictly observed.
210.
Article 54 of the constitution states that executive power lies with the
president of the republic. He is the head of government and, as such, he
determines and implements national policy. Paragraph 5 of the same article
says that the duties of the members of government are different from the duties
of MPs. Under Article 79, Parliament is formed by a National Assembly
whose members are called MPs. It has legislative power and also monitors
government activities. Article 92 states that an MP appointed to a ministerial
position shall lose the right to sit in Parliament. Similar provisions on the
judiciary deal with the differences and independence of Supreme and
Constitutional Court members, and members of government or Parliament.
92