level or through the conciliation mechanism involving the NCEW and MOLHW. When the dispute cannot be resolved, however, the parties can go either for arbitration or to the First instance Labor Board Court. In the case of individual labor dispute, the arbitral award at this level has the same effect as the decision of the First Instance Labor Court. But, if the case is a collective labor dispute, the decision at this level has the same effect as the decision of the Labor Relations Board. Any party dissatisfied with the arbitral award has appeal right to the concerned higher court. Trade Unions and organizational Dynamics 229. Trade unions have been established in work places. A significant update of the Labor Proclamation 8/1991 of 1991 that featured in Proclamation 118/2001 was the further clarification and consolidation of the right to organize in the work places. It is predicated on the concrete development situation and transformations taking place including on labor rights in Eritrea. The proclamation also reflected the principles enshrined in the ILO conventions and recommendations. On the other hand, the revised Proclamation further reinforced the firm conviction that workers and employers, without distinction whatsoever, have the right to establish and to join organizations of their own choice with a view to defend their respective interests. 230. At independence in 1991, there were 60 trade unions with a total of 5760 members (3450 male and 2220 female). This increased to 211 by 1998 (14679 male and 7118 female employees). The situation is reflected in the following table:Number of Base Unions by number of workers according to gender Year 1999 Male 14,964 Female 7,350 Total 22,314 Total No of Unions 219 2005 11,817 7,287 19,104 257 2011 2015 Average/year 12,868 18,720 14,592 8,496 7,280 7,603 21,364 26,000 22,195 235 168 220 231. By virtue of the Labor proclamation 118/2001, the autonomy of trade unions in Eritrea has been effectively guaranteed. This has also been promoted under the provisions of the transitional civil code and the new Civil Code published recently. Labor unions have their own constitutions, elect their representatives freely, organize their own administration and activities and formulate their plans and actions. They also conduct regular and timely congresses, organize conferences, meetings and activities to strengthen their organizational capacity and raise their visibility in the wider communities and constituents they serve. The acquisition of legal personality by these organizations is not subject to restrictive conditions. 232. Public authorities are thus prohibited from any interference which might restrict the exercise of such rights. The mandate of the authorities in the exercise of this right has only Page 56 of 100

Select target paragraph3