(2017) 1 African Human Rights Yearbook
45
property.18 Further, the Commission has highlighted that ensuring non
discrimination in the right to property requires ’measures to modify or
prohibit harmful social, cultural or other practices that prevent women
and other members of vulnerable and disadvantaged groups from
enjoying their right to property, particularly in relation to housing and
land.’19
As in most parts of the world however, the denial of women’s land
and property rights in Africa is pervasive. This is in spite of the widely
accepted importance of women’s control, and access to land and
property to development goals. To date, systemic and systematic
violations of women’s land and property rights exist in many African
countries in the form of statutory and customary laws, policies and
practices and social norms that are widely discriminatory. These
patriarchal beliefs and ideologies are deeply entrenched in the various
ways through which women acquire rights to land and property.
A number of African countries have dual legal systems, with
statutory law coexisting with customary or religious laws. Owing to the
patriarchal beliefs as highlighted above and how a significant number
of people’s affairs end up being regulated through customary law the
land and property rights of a large number of women have therefore
been very precarious. In many instances, concerning women’s land and
property rights, discriminatory customary laws have tended to
dominate land tenure systems, resulting in women’s access to land or
property being closely tied to their relationship to a man – as daughters,
wives, widows and sisters. In some countries where laws have been
enacted that prohibit discrimination, and constitutions guarantee
equality, the application of these provisions to family and personal laws
is exempted. Further, power imbalances and stereotypes within the
family and home particularly around the role of women significantly
pose threats to realisation of women’s property rights.
As Banning points out, the right to property has linkages with a host
of other rights.20 The right to equality is one of these rights. That
equality and property are closely linked cannot be doubted and there
can be no question that in addition to the direct enforceability of
property rights, equality jurisprudence has a critical role to play in
securing women’s rights to land and property. Putting this perspective
forward, Bulto has propositioned that ‘whenever a given socioeconomic right is infringed, it usually leads to, results from or is
accompanied by the violation of one or a combination of the right to
equality, the right to judicial protection and the right to due process. A
redress to the latter could also remedy violations of socio-economic
rights.’21 This article proceed on the same assumption that the effective
18
African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights ‘Principles And Guidelines on
the Implementation of Economic, Social And Cultural Rights In The African Charter On
Human And Peoples’ Rights’ http://www.achpr.org/files/instruments/economic-socialcultural/achpr_instr_guide_draft_esc_rights_eng.pdf 53 (accessed 17 September
2017).
19
Principles and Guidelines on Implementation of ESCRR (n 18 above) 55.
20
Van Banning (n 7 above).
21
Bulto (n 3 above) 143.