(2017) 1 African Human Rights Yearbook
3
31
PROTECTION OF THE CHILD UNDER THE
AFRICAN HUMAN RIGHTS SYSTEM
Under the African human rights system there are particularly two
instruments which are of significance in the protection of the rights of
children, namely, the African Children’s Rights Charter and in the case
of the girl child, the African Women’s Rights Protocol. These two
instruments are undergirded by the rights protected in the African
Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (African Charter), but, for the
current purposes, reliance will be placed on the former two
instruments, insofar as they provide more extensive protection of the
rights of the child. However, where there is no relevant provision on a
specific right in either of these instruments, regard will be had to the
African Charter itself. This section will deal with the vulnerabilities set
out above under specific but interrelated themes of rights, starting with
the rights/principles at the core of the African Children’s Rights
Charter and then looking at rights related to a clean environment,
education, migration and access to information and participation, in an
attempt to ascertain the responsibilities which this places on African
states.
3.1
Basic principles in the African Children’s Rights
Charter
There are a number of principles which are set out at the start of the
African Children’s Rights Charter, which form the bedrock of the other
rights protected in the Charter, but which are also rights in
themselves.37 The first in the right to non-discrimination, which is set
out in article 3 of the Children’s Charter and provides that every child is
entitled to the enjoyment of the rights in this Charter, irrespective of a
number of grounds of discrimination, including ethnic group, colour,
sex, language and social origin.38 The right not to be discriminated
against is a right which applies both by itself, and in conjunction with
other rights. As a right in itself, the prohibition of discrimination on the
ground of sex, for example, means that there may not be discrimination
against girl children. However, while formal equality may be easy to
37
These ‘four pillars’ were originally identified by the United Nations Committee on
the Rights of the Child as forming the basis of the United Nations Convention on the
Rights of the Child, but they equally apply to the African Children’s Charter.
38
The right to non-discrimination and equality is also a general principle of human
rights and can similarly be found in article 2 of the African Charter and article 2 of the
African Women’s Rights Protocol, with slight variances as to the grounds of
discrimination which are prohibited, the latter obviously focussed on sex and gender.
Various provisions under the African Women’s Rights Protocol have also been
interpreted as having a character of transformative equality, which goes beyond formal
and substantive equality in order to change the values and ‘underlying structure’ of a
society. See S Fredman ‘Beyond the dichotomy of formal and substantive equality:
towards new definitions of equal rights’ in I Boerefijn et al (eds) Temporary special
measures: accelerating de facto equality of women under article 4(1) UN Convention
on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (2003) 111.