CHAPTER THREE: DEMOCRACY AND POLITICAL GOVERNANCE
__________________________________________________________________________
blocking important anti-corruption laws that would restore the authority of the
state. Add to this the numerous and persistent rumours of corruption in the
national Parliament and there can be hardly any doubt that there is an urgent
need for a programme to restore the image of Parliament and to build its
capacity.
222.
The independence of the judiciary. The independence of the judiciary should
be understood as the independence of all the courts. This includes special
courts like the High Court of Justice and the Constitutional Court, which hears
cases of violations of human rights.
223.
The independence of judges in Benin is guaranteed by important laws like the
constitution; Establishment Act 94-027 of 15 June 1999 on the JSC; Law
2001-35 of 21 February 2003, which establishes the judiciary; and the acts
establishing the Constitutional Court, the High Court of Justice and the
Supreme Court. The new statutes for members of the Supreme Court are in the
process of being adopted.
224.
Judges in Benin, for the most part, are not subjected to temporary mandates for
the exercise of their functions. They are appointed for life. Only the president
of the Supreme Court and members of the Constitutional Court and the High
Court of Justice are appointed for a fixed term. Judges of the Constitutional
Court and the High Court of Justice are not necessarily members of the
national legal service, but the security of their jobs is guaranteed by the
principle of irremovability. This is one feature that is accepted by all legal
systems as evidence of the independence of the judiciary of a country. It is
enshrined in Article 115 Paragraph 4, Article 126 Paragraph 2, and Article 133
Paragraph 2 of the Constitution.
225.
Pursuant to Law 2001-35 of 21 February 2003, which establishes the judiciary,
the appointment of a judge can only be terminated on disciplinary grounds and
in accordance with specified procedures (also used for state prosecutors) by
the JSC.
226.
Some provisions of the constitution, however, make the independence of the
judiciary relative. In terms of Articles 127-130, the president of the republic is
also the head of the Executive. He guarantees the independence of the courts
and appoints judges. The constitution gives the JSC – which is the body that
disciplines judges – the role of assistant and adviser to the president. The
minister of justice shares the vice-chairmanship of the JSC together with the
president of the Supreme Court. He nominates judges for appointment, and
initiates and conducts investigations into disciplinary matters concerning
judges brought before the JSC. The strong presence of the Executive on the
JSC and the subordinate role of the JSC – the body that guarantees and
preserves the independence of the judiciary – are serious violations of the
principles of the separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary.
227.
It is thus very appropriate that the Constitutional Court has endeavoured to
make up for the gaps in the conditions governing the independence and
irremovability of judges. The Constitutional Court has ruled that the approval
96