(2017) 1 African Human Rights Yearbook
77
the FPTP system is that women candidates will be competing with men
or other women directly, and voters will be focussing on the traits of an
individual candidate. Because of patriarchy and stereotypes against
women, voters often prefer male candidates above women candidates.
This is different to the proportional representation electoral system, in
which voters focus on the political party and its policies and
programmes rather than on individual candidates. With proportional
representation, more women are elected into office than in
majoritarian systems.87 As evidence, a review of 53 national
legislatures in 1999 found that National Assemblies elected by
proportional representation were composed, on average, by nearly 20
per cent women, compared to only about 11 per cent in majoritarian
systems.88
The triumph of female candidates in elections is also affected by the
strenuous process used to select candidates. Matland argues that, ‘for
women to get elected to parliament they need to pass three crucial
barriers; first, they need to select themselves to stand for elections;
second, they need to get selected as candidate by the party, and thirdly,
they need to get selected by voters’.89 At each stage, women face
peculiar challenges that they must overcome before moving on to the
next stage.
At the primary election stage, candidates are selected by internal
party structures through a rigorous and often flawed process. In
Zimbabwe, party primary elections ahead of the 2013 were marred with
irregularities, and reports of women being intimidated by men, and
some male candidates absconding with ballot boxes.90 The influential
role of ‘male’ gatekeepers who block women’s entry into politics
remains one of the most serious impediments to women’s inclusion in
primary election processes. ‘Men dominate the political arena; men
formulate the rules of the political game; and men define the standards
for evaluation. This male-dominated model results in either women
shunning politics altogether or rejecting male-style politics’.91 Male
leaders in political parties often favour their male friends, and a few
female colleagues. In some cases, women candidates succeed through
forging strong alliances with male leaders, even if this may mean
providing male leaders with sexual favours.92 This belief has seen many
women, especially married women, shunning contesting for political
party positions.
Violence and intimidation further limit women’s participation in
public life. A baseline study conducted by Gender Links revealed
87
88
89
90
91
92
A M Goetz No shortcuts to power (2003).
Goetz (n 87 above) 51.
Matland (n 86 above) 66.
Dziva et al (n 14 above).
Shvedova (n 28 above) 21.
Dziva et al (n 14 above).