(2018) 2 African Human Rights Yearbook
105
On a related note, it is of some significance that we were unable to
find any domestic decisions referring to decisions rendered by the
African Court or the African Committee of Experts on the Rights of the
Child (African Children’s Rights Committee). This may be, in part, due
to the relatively more recent establishment of the African Court93 and
African Children’s Rights Committee,94 as compared to the African
Commission.95
3.7
Other soft law instruments in the AU system
Aside from the African Charter, related treaties and the Commission’s
jurisprudence, we identified two cases in which courts had referred to
AU soft law instruments – in both cases generated by the African
Commission.96
In the first place, in Onyango Obbo,97 Justice Mulenga, who wrote
the lead judgment, noted that while article 9 of the African Charter
simply provided for the right to receive information and disseminate
opinions, the African Commission had, in October 2002, adopted a
Declaration on Principles on Freedom of Expression in Africa (FoE
Declaration) in order ‘to elaborate and expound on the nature, content
and extent of the right provided for under article 9’.98 He then cited and
relied upon Principles 1 and 2 of the Declaration which, according to
him, had provided greater clarity regarding the scope of the right under
article 9 of the African Charter.99 In the end, the Supreme Court made
far reaching pronouncements on the nature and scope of the right to
freedom of expression in Uganda (article 29 of the Constitution), in a
decision which continues to be the classic case on this point in Uganda’s
constitutional jurisprudence.
Similarly, in Mulago,100 Judge Mugambe referred to the African
Commission’s Principles and Guidelines on the Implementation of
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
The African Court was instituted by the Protocol to the African Charter on the
Establishment of an African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the Court
Protocol), which was adopted by the Assembly of the OAU on 9 June 1998. The
Protocol entered into force on 25 January 2004, and the first 11 judges of the
Court were inaugurated on 2 July 2006 – Viljoen (n 3) 412-413.
The African Children’s Charter was adopted on 11 July 1990, but only came into
force on 29 November 1999. The first 11 members of the African Children’s Rights
Committee were elected by the OAU Assembly in July 2001 - Viljoen (n 3) 391397.
The African Commission was established under the African Charter, which was
adopted in 1981, and which entered into force on 21 October 1986. The initial 11
Commissioners held their first session on 2 November 1987 - Viljoen (n 3) 289290.
The Commission’s jurisprudence may also be considered to be AU soft law. For an
extended consideration of the nature and scope of soft law, see B Kabumba (2018)
Soft law and legitimacy in international law.
n 18.
At 8, citing the African Commission Declaration.
At 8.
n 50.