The application of African Union (human
rights) law in Uganda: trends and prospects
from a comparative review
Busingye Kabumba*
ABSTRACT: The body of public international law that may be known as
‘African Union (AU) law’, that is to say, the treaties, resolutions, constitutive
documents, jurisprudence and practices of the AU, now constitute a
respectable corpus of legal material. However, not only is this body of law
under-theorised and under-studied by general public international law
scholars, the nature of its reception and application within the domestic legal
orders of AU member states is even more neglected. This article seeks to
address the dearth of scholarship in this regard by critically analysing the
judicial reference to AU law in one African country – Uganda – having
particular regard to the reception of human rights related AU law.
TITRE ET RÉSUMÉ EN FRANCAIS:
L’application du droit (des droits de l’homme) de l’Union africaine en
Ouganda: une analyse comparée des tendances et perspectives
RÉSUMÉ: Le corpus du droit international public pouvant être dénommé ‘droit de
l’Union africaine’, composé des traités, des résolutions, des documents statutaires, de
la jurisprudence et des pratiques de l’UA constituent désormais un corpus respectable
de textes juridiques. Cependant, non seulement ces normes juridiques sont sousétudiées et sous-théorisées par les spécialistes du droit international public général
mais encore la nature de leur incorporation et de leur application dans l’ordre
juridique internes des États membres de l’Union africaine est encore plus négligée.
Cet article conduit une analyse critique de la référence à ces normes par les
juridictions de un pays africain – l’Ouganda – avec un accent particulier sur la
réception et l’intégration des normes de l’Union africaine en matière des droits de
l’homme.
KEY WORDS: African Union law, regional economic communities, Ugandan
judiciary, East African Community, European Union
*
LLB (Makerere), BCL (Oxford), LLMC (Harvard) LLD (Pretoria); Lecturer, School
of Law, Makerere University; kbusingy@ gmail.com. I am deeply grateful to the
anonymous reviewers and editors of the Yearbook, whose valuable and insightful
comments on earlier drafts of this article, greatly enhanced the quality of this
work. I am greatly indebted to the Africa Oxford Initiative (AfOX) and the Faculty
of Law of the University of Oxford, for the award of the inaugural AfOx-Law
Visiting Fellowship for the period October to November 2018; and to St. Anne’s
College, Oxford, for the award of a Plumer Visiting Fellowship covering the same
duration. This article would not have seen the light of day but for the opportunity
for thought and reflection provided by these Fellowships. My sincere thanks, as
such, to Jonathan Herring, Kevin Marsh, Anne Makena, Liora Lazarus, Imogen
Goold, Antonios Tzanakopoulos, and many others too numerous to mention
individually. All errors and omissions in the article, of course, remain solely mine.
89
B Kabumba ‘The application of African Union (human rights) law in Uganda: trends and prospects from a comparative
review’ (2018) 2 African Human Rights Yearbook 89-130
http://doi.org/10.29053/2523-1367/2018/v2n1a5