CHAPTER THREE: DEMOCRACY AND POLITICAL GOVERNANCE
239.
The entanglement of the executive and legislative powers is to be noted: the
particularly wide constitutional delimitation of the legislative powers of the
APN; interference in the regulatory authority of the executive; and imbalance
of powers in favour of the head of government to the detriment of the
President, who is nonetheless elected by the nation. This points to the need for
constitutional amendment to remedy the situation.
ii.
Findings of the CRM
240.
As far as the independence of the judiciary is concerned, the CRM notes the
will of the constituent assembly to enshrine and guarantee the independence of
the judicial authorities formally. All the formal guarantees of these powers are,
in effect, enshrined in the Constitution. Nonetheless, the President of the
Republic who presides over the Executive also presides over the Higher
Council of the Magistracy, which is the body guaranteeing the independence
of the judicial system and governing the careers of judges. This could prove to
be both ambiguous and restrictive in relation to the judicial power.
241.
This is borne out by the fact that the tenure of judges is only relative and there
is no marked difference in the functions of the prosecutor‟s office and the
bench, or between those of the investigative judge and the examining judge,
and even less between those of the administrative judge and the judicial judge.
The transition from one function to the other and from one jurisdiction to the
other occurs at the instance of appointments by the President of the Republic,
on the recommendation of the Higher Council of the Magistracy over which
he presides, and the deputy presidency of which is assured by the Minister of
Justice, who is the guardian of the seals and is completely separate from the
government.
242.
It is noteworthy, on another aspect, that magistrates in Algeria enjoy the right
to unionise, various financial guarantees and an ensured independence and are
subject to reviews by their peers. The Code of Ethics for magistrates
promulgated by the Higher Council of the Magistracy (Official Gazette 17 of
2007) compels magistrates to declare their assets at each promotion, as well as
every five years. They are also prevented from belonging to any political
party. This guarantees the ethical requirements and the will to combat
corruption within the judicial system.
243.
Although the statutory guarantees for a judge are considerable, it is still true
that there is continued criticism of the allegiance of a large number of judges
to the government in the handling of sensitive cases. This is borne out by the
February 2007 opinion survey, according to which only 5.8 per cent of those
surveyed considered the degree of independence of the judiciary to be very
high, 19.4 per cent considered it high, 37.6 per cent average, 26.0 per cent
insufficient and 11.2 per cent completely inadequate. In other words, over half
of the respondents have a negative opinion of the independence of the
judiciary in their country. Opinions vary quite significantly as regards access
86