of conflict in the country. In addition, some families that are deemed
‘settlers’ in reality have ancestral ties to the land, having settled in the
area generations ago, but are nevertheless regarded as having inferior
entitlement. The constitution has not managed to resolve this contradiction
and the dichotomy therefore creates unequal access to social services at
the local government level. The example that was cited in many states
such as Plateau, Nassarawa, Adamawa and Benue was unequal access to
education, whereby indigenes have free access while settlers are charged
for accessing education. This situation naturally creates animosities in the
communities, since the national constitution provides for access to free
primary, secondary, university and adult education.
188.
Some states are beginning to address the indigene-settler dichotomy by
reinterpreting the contradictions in the national constitution. Indeed,
Niger State has sought to reverse the application of the Federal Character
Principle, which has historically emphasised indigeneity at the expense of
residency by granting indigeneship to those who have resided in the state
for eight years. Consequently, those who meet the residency requirements
can access all the benefits of the state, including contesting for state and
federal appointments. However, this is the exception rather than the
rule. In states such as Plateau, Borno, Adamawa, Benue, Akwa Ibom and
Bayelsa, a number of stakeholders expressed frustration at the lack of
citizenship rights as a result of the application of this principle.
189.
Although structural in nature, some conflicts have also manifested
themselves in the form of religious intolerance between Muslims and
Christians, especially in the northeastern, north-central and northwestern
parts of Nigeria. In Borno State, for example, the CRM was informed that
a religious upheaval in 2006 resulted from the publication in Denmark
of a cartoon depicting the Prophet Mohammed. The Muslim community
in Borno subsequently burnt down a Christian church in revenge for this
incident. The conflict receded only at the intervention of the Borno State
governor. This is not an isolated case: throughout the northern and central
states there have been numerous episodes of communal conflicts arising
from religious intolerance between Christians and Muslims.
190.
The Nigerian constitution guarantees freedom of religion while recognising
Nigeria as a secular state. But religion, like ethnicity, is regularly politicised
by the political elite as a tool to achieve the narrow political goals of both
individuals and groups in Nigeria. There was a bitter national debate
when the northern state of Zamfara became the first state to implement
the Islamic Sharia law in its entirety in January 2000. By the end of 2001,
such other northern states as Kebbi, Sokoto, Niger, Kaduna, Bauchi and
Borno had fully established Islamic law. The imposition of strict Islamic
law in multifaith communities has attracted much debate and criticism in
a country already considered a hotbed of religious conflicts.
191.
Closely linked to the issue of social inequalities and poverty is the issue of
youth unemployment, delinquency and alienation that ultimately creates
opportunities for abuse by political elites and business interests. During
elections, disgruntled and abandoned youths are recruited by unscrupulous
politicians who practise ‘sit-tight’ politics in order to cause violence and
83